When you think of Chicago, dogs come to mind. And I don't mean my 5 pound attack dog, Rusty. I'm talking about a Vienna beef dog on a steamed poppy seed bun with yellow mustard, bright green relish, a dill pickle, tomatoes, celery salt, chopped onion and sport peppers (small pickled peppers from the cayenne family). I'd never had one before, and I thought the best time to do a hot dog taste test was when my friend Kari finally came to visit. Kari loves meat. Particularly encased meat. She is hot dog crazy.
So on a sunny Monday in April, Kari came in to go to the Cubs opening day game (thanks for the tickets Dick Starmann!! Who gives away their opening day tickets??? True generosity.). After a beer at the Red Ivy, Kari and I headed into Wrigley to glory in our awesome seats. After the first pitch was thrown, however, we headed through the tunnel in search of a dog.
First, we went to the "Chicago Dogs" stand. Apparently a favorite of R.G. Starmann, this dog was a little lackluster to us. They didn't have all of the toppings, and the dog hadn't seen the grill for long enough, in my opinion. After scoping out ALL the other stands in the ballpark, we decided to try a "Footlong Dog" for round two. In fairness, the footlong dogs didn't have the right bun, and offered a number of additional toppings (Jackie loves sauerkraut) that don't a Chicago-dog make. There is no chili involved. Round two was surprisingly delicious. May have been the Old Style.
Now nothing quite compares to a dog in the ballpark, but Kari and I both felt that we hadn't experienced the real thing. After some careful research on good dog joints in Chicago (Wiener Circle and Superdawg also made the top five), we decided to have lunch at Hot Doug's (The self-proclaimed "Sausage Superstore and Encased Meat Emporium") the next day.
Hot Doug's is kind of legendary around these parts. I first heard about the place from my friend Dan, who swears by Doug's dogs. I was told to anticipate an hour's wait, but a great lunch. Kari and I arrived at noon, and found quick parking (this place is in the middle of nowhere!) and a surprisingly short line. We were at the counter in less than 10 minutes.
Doug, who takes everyone's order himself, has about 10 dogs and sausages that are on the menu every day and a dozen more specials. When we got up to the counter (after posing for a pic with Doug) Kari got "The Marty Allen" ... a Thuringer dog (Hello der beef, pork and garlic) with spicy mustard and a dill pickle. I got "The Dog" (A Chicago-style dog with all the trimmings). We also split one of the specials...a Weisswurst with spicy mustard, kraut, and shredded horseradish-cheddar cheese. All were ordered "a little burnt". Mmmm. A side of hand-cut fries rounded out our gluttony.
We sat at a tiny table with our bounty before us. Now I should mention, I usually don't like hot dogs unless they have so much crap on top that you don't even know you're eating a dog. The only dogs I have ever really enjoyed were from Yesterdog in Grand Rapids (get the killer dog...it's not on the menu, but you won't be disappointed. It is literally towering with crap on top. Heaven.)
Doug's dogs won me over. Perfectly grilled so that the skin was toasty, but not split open yet, these dogs were super flavorful. The bun was warm and didn't disintegrate like the ones at the ballpark the day before. The toppings were fresh and added in good proportion. The french fries were double fried and extra crispy. The photo above is Kari's pic of the feast before we dug in (she strangely photographed all our dogs during her visit).
Kari and I even checked out Doug and noted his lack of wedding ring. I think she could really love a man who runs a hot dog empire. This place was so good that I even bought a T-shirt. Really? Yes, I did.
So after 3 hot dogs in 2 days, I finally feel qualified to weigh in on Chicago's most famous namesake food. I'm in. Thank you Doug, and bring on the sport peppers.